The PIP scandal could provide a landmark case for medical tourism

 

In December 2011, news broke that breast implantssupplied by the French manufacturer, Poly Implant Prosthèse (PIP) and used in Europe since 2001 contain sub-standard non-medical grade silicone. The rupture rate in PIP breast implants was confirmed as being much higher than other types of silicone. So, concerns were raised that when they do rupture, they release non-medical-grade silicone into the body, and this may have harmful effects. Disgruntled patients are fighting for compensation and the removal and replacement of these implants.

Could medical tourism agencies be held liable?

Medical negligence law within Europe mostly assumes that the hospital/clinic is liable for any negligent act, although in some cases the doctor/ surgeon can also be personally liable.

But the law has not caught up with the world of medical tourism where the customer arranges treatment via a medical tourism agent; and there are many unanswered questions on whether the agent is an agent of the customer or of the hospital or both.

Agencies have assumed that, as most claims are in tort (a civil case for negligence), that they cannot be guilty of anything, as they have no control over the medical procedures. But it appears likely that class actions on PIP implants will be under contract law, which makes the person the customer dealt with the primary culprit. This could be deemed to be the agent or facilitator.

Planned class/group actions from 50 law firms on behalf of 40,000 UK women who had PIP implants may, or may not, produce guidance. The claims could be made both under standard negligence (tort) and also under contract law. Under contract law, the argument is whether or not the contract is with the hospital or with the agent or the surgeon, or some combination. In any group action it would be normal for lawyers to jointly sue the agency and the clinic to ensure no wriggle room and leave the defendants to argue who pays what share of any damages and costs.

The need for professional indemnity insurance

This case could be a benchmark for medical tourism as if the agency is also or even solely legally responsible under contract and/ or tort it would make it vital for all such agencies to buy professional indemnity insurance. Few buy this at present but there are special covers around for medical tourism. Many small agencies do not buy it as it is not cheap and they feel that they are not legally liable. If a claim succeeds against an agency with no insurance, then it could bankrupt the company. If the agency is not a company but run as a sole trader, the claim would be against the owner’s personal assets. This may be a good argument for all agencies to trade as a limited company, not as a sole trader or partnership.

Taking UK patients as an example, whether they had treatment in the UK or Europe, if they dealt direct with the clinic then the clinic is the one to sue. But if they dealt via an agent, they may sue the agent, not the clinic. Bearing in mind the number of people who could sue, and the number of lawyers involved, the defence costs, even if the clinics and agencies are proved totally innocent, could be huge.

40,000 women in Britain have undergone breast surgery or breast enlargement using PIP implants,.  Private clinics / hospitals performed 95% of the related operations; the remainder were carried out by the NHS. The implants contain industrial rather than medical grade silicone. Following the recall of the implants by the French medical regulatory authority, PIP went into liquidation.

Who pays?

The issue, for patients and their legal advisers is what is to be done and who is to pay.  For patients treated privately who, if anyone, is legally responsible for the predicament in which they now find themselves? Breast augmentation surgery is a works and materials contract and is governed by The Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 (SGSA), which requires goods supplied under such contracts to be of satisfactory quality (SGSA section 2). The normal defence of the costs of rectifying the damage being too high in relation to the problem is unlikely to work here. So the women can sue for the costs of having the product removed and/or replaced. The remedies are exercisable against the person with whom the patient had entered into the contract for the supply of goods and services.

Usually this will be with the clinic.  In some cases the claim may be made against the surgeon who performed the surgery. In some cases where the patient had an exclusive contract with a third party who then sub-contracted to purchase theatre facilities and nursing care from a hospital or clinic and surgical skills from a surgeon it is likely that only the third party contractor could be claimed against since in such circumstances the patient is unlikely to have had a contract with the sub-contractors.

A negligence claim can be an alternative, as it is not necessary for there to be a contractual link between the parties to the action:  one need only show that the defendant owed the claimant a duty of care, and such duty has been breached.   This breach of duty could apply equally to the surgeon, the clinic and the agent.

Ian Adamson of Bircham Dyson Bell comments, “With action against the manufacturer futile, the most likely means of redress for an affected patient is a claim against the person with whom she had the contract for her treatment.  Who this is will vary from case to case, and will not necessarily be the hospital where the procedure was carried out or the surgeon who performed it.”

If a medical tourism agency is operating without professional negligence cover, is it putting its business at risk?

FURTHER CONTENT PUBLISHED BY THIS AUTHOR

Top 25 medical travel destinations

Articles, 16 May, 2018

IMTJ's latest estimate on leading destinations by medical tourism revenue

Medical Tourism: Who’s in and who’s out?

Resources, 30 April, 2018

Keith Pollard, International Medical Travel Journal, IMTJ Medical Travel Summit USA 2018

UK infertility tourism

Articles, 11 July, 2017

NHS shortcomings driving fertility treatment abroad

Vetting the realities of global medical travel

Resources, 01 May, 2017

Keith Pollard, Destination Health: The Medical Travel Summit USA

How to create a unique value proposition in medical tourism

Resources, 26 April, 2017

Keith Pollard, IMTJ, IMTJ Medical Travel Summit 2017

Targeting the UK medical tourist

Resources, 26 April, 2017

Keith Pollard, IMTJ, IMTJ Medical Travel Summit 2017

Prepare for the future of medical tourism

Resources, 25 April, 2017

Keith Pollard, IMTJ, IMTJ Medical Travel Summit 2017

Foolish foray

Articles, 01 April, 2017

IMTJ launches medical tourism fake news service

Medical tourism market growth?

Articles, 21 March, 2017

Is the medical tourism market growing?

Target UK medical tourists?

Articles, 09 March, 2017

Should I target the UK for medical tourism?

Medical tourism market size

Articles, 06 March, 2017

How big is the medical tourism market?

5 key medical tourism questions

Articles, 23 February, 2017

Medical tourism... market size, growth, opportunities

The role of "online" medical tourism

Resources, 21 October, 2016

Keith Pollard: 7th Global Healthcare & Medical Tourism Conference

Delivering an outstanding international patient experience

Resources, 09 October, 2016

Keith Pollard, Intuition Communication Ltd: IMTJ Masterclass 2016

When will medical tourism reach the tipping point?

Resources, 26 May, 2016

Keith Pollard, Intuition Communication: IMTJ Summit 2016

Marketing health tourism on the web

Resources, 16 March, 2016

Keith Pollard: The 2nd Bursa Medical & Thermal Tourism Forum

What makes a destination attractive?

Resources, 16 March, 2016

Keith Pollard: The 2nd Bursa Medical & Thermal Tourism Forum

Does your online presence reflect the quality of your care?

Resources, 16 October, 2015

Keith Pollard: IMTEC 2015

Third age healthcare

Articles, 25 August, 2015

Opportunities in health tourism for the "third age"

What do we know about medical tourists?

Resources, 15 April, 2015

Keith Pollard: IMTJ Summit 2015

The EU Directive Getting the Message Across

Resources, 15 April, 2015

Keith Pollard: IMTJ Summit 2015

Best of 2014

Articles, 06 January, 2015

The top ten most popular medical tourism articles in 2014

Lessons from Passport2Health

Articles, 22 April, 2014

What can be learned from Passport2Health's failure?

Flying blind

Articles, 10 February, 2014

The risks of medical tourism are hard to find

Top ten of 2013

Articles, 06 January, 2014

The most popular medical tourism articles of 2013

The Kreativ solution

Articles, 20 November, 2013

The secret of Budapest's success in dental tourism.

Report from MIHTE 2013

Articles, 22 October, 2013

Government and providers must work together to drive a destination

Cyprus at a crossroads

Articles, 09 August, 2013

The future plans for Cyprus as a medical tourism centre

Cross Border Healthcare

Articles, 29 July, 2013

What is it all about?

PriceWatch 2013

Articles, 23 July, 2013

Participate in IMJT's price transparency survey

New councils launched

Articles, 02 April, 2013

Two new bodies are trying to bring together medical travel

Survey of medical tourism sector

Articles, 02 April, 2013

Survey highlights the fragmented nature of medical tourism

Malaysia, the best kept secret

Articles, 03 December, 2012

How Malaysia is developing as a medical tourism destination

Hungary ....Europe's no 1 destination for dental tourists

Resources, 14 June, 2012

Keith Pollard

Ten things you need to know about medical tourism

Resources, 27 April, 2012

Keith Pollard: EMTC 2012

How to turn the web "window shopper"? into a paying patient

Resources, 27 April, 2012

Keith Pollard: EMTC 2012

All that glisters

Articles, 10 April, 2012

San Serriffe made an impact on the medical travel world, but never existed

What's in a brand name?

Articles, 06 March, 2012

What part of a brand does a customer remember the logo, the name, or their treatment?

Trends for 2012

Articles, 30 December, 2011

We look at the future of medical tourism in 2012

Everyone's a critic

Articles, 18 November, 2011

Medical tourism has a bad reputation, but what can we do about that?

Turkey, bucking the trend

Articles, 04 November, 2011

In a difficult market Turkey is still making progress, but why?

Medical tourism: Past Present and Future

Resources, 02 November, 2011

Keith Pollard: International Health Tourism Congress in Istanbul

Misspell Bumrungrad? Visit the MTA

Articles, 27 October, 2011

MTA's domain registration activities steal away Bumrungrad's visitors

Gamete shortage

Articles, 27 October, 2011

Will changes to donation payment help solve the lack of UK sperm and eggs donations

Do we need an EU Health Tourism Certificate?

Resources, 12 October, 2011

Keith Pollard: EU Symposium, "Health tourism - Establishing a new culture in Europe"

Can Europe lead the way?

Articles, 07 October, 2011

Can Cross Border Healthcare help develop medical tourism in Europe

An introduction to medical travel

Resources, 06 October, 2011

Keith Pollard: Latvian Health Tourism seminar

Marketing medical tourism online

Resources, 06 October, 2011

Keith Pollard: Latvian Health Tourism seminar

The future of spa tourism

Articles, 01 August, 2011

Dr László Puczkó presents a report on the future of spa tourism.

The Slumbering Giant of Medical Travel: the UK in the medical tourism market

Resources, 25 May, 2011

Keith Pollard: EMTC 2011

Medical tourism: International Patient Streams Past , present, and future

Resources, 04 May, 2011

Keith Pollard: EMTC 2011

Medical Tourism: After the Goldrush

Resources, 04 May, 2011

Keith Pollard: EMTC 2011

Thousands, not millions

Articles, 05 January, 2011

A new study reveals the real numbers of American medical tourism

Opportunities in health tourism: World Travel Market 2010

Resources, 12 November, 2010

Keith Pollard: World Travel Market 2010

Where are we now?

Articles, 17 September, 2010

An update on the EU directive on Cross Border Healthcare

Abandon ship!

Articles, 06 August, 2010

Keith Pollard explains why we should abandon medical tourism

Recession proof?

Articles, 02 July, 2010

Keith Pollard talks on why infertility tourism could be recession proof

Future of Medical tourism: Presentation

Resources, 30 June, 2010

Keith Pollard: Destination Health, London Olympia 2010

The Do's and Don'ts of Medical Tourism

Resources, 30 June, 2010

Chris Fearne: Malta Medical Tourism Summit 2009

Climate Survey 2010 results

Articles, 10 May, 2010

Keith Pollard reports on the IMTJ Medical Tourism climate survey

What is a medical tourist?

Articles, 12 March, 2010

Medical tourism statistics: Comparing apples with apples ....

The outlook for 2010

Articles, 14 January, 2010

Reality bites in the market, what can we expect for 2010?

Patients judging quality

Articles, 27 November, 2009

How can patients make an informed choice?

Marketing medical tourism: Malta Conference

Resources, 20 July, 2009

Keith Pollard: Malta Medical Tourism Summit 2009

Past experience and patient choice

Articles, 09 July, 2009

Keith Pollard talks on how patient choice is affecting the market?

Winners and losers in medical travel: International Medical Travel presentations

Resources, 19 November, 2008

Keith Pollard: IMTC 2008

Advertisement

ADD AN ARTICLE

Do you have an article that you’d like to share with the medical travel industry?

Publish for FREE on IMTJ.

ADD ARTICLE

Related Articles

Iran medical tourism sector

10 July, 2019

Can Iran broaden its healthcare appeal?

Healthcare innovation in Korea

14 May, 2019

Targeting the complex care patient: Korea’s rising global status

UK non-surgical cosmetic surgery

18 April, 2019

UK non-surgical cosmetic market: a crisis waiting to happen?

Turkey inbound medical tourism

06 December, 2018

Medical travel to Turkey is increasing

Tele-surgery and medical tourism

22 March, 2017

Is tele-surgery a threat to medical tourism?